Betsy Menu

Welcome to Betsy, a charming café located in the heart of Island Bay, Wellington. Famous for its cozy ambiance and friendly staff, Betsy offers a menu brimming with delightful choices. Start your day with their indulgent Crumpets, topped with passion fruit curd and vanilla bean cream cheese, or enjoy the luxurious French Toast, perfectly paired with berry compote.

For those with a sweet tooth, Betsy’s in-house Cake Slices and freshly made Doughnuts are must-tries, while vegan options like the Peanut Raw Slice ensure inclusivity for all diners. The drink selection, featuring Karma Drinks and Aroha Juice, perfectly complements any meal.

Each visit promises warmth and excellent service, making Betsy not just a café, but a beloved gathering spot. Whether you're indulging in a sweet treat or savoring a masterfully brewed coffee, every bite and sip at Betsy is a celebration of quality and care.

Betsy Bagels

• Salmon

  Silky smoked salmon, tangy capers, fresh dill, and creamy cheese spread. Gluten-free available.

  NZ$17.20

• Blue Cheese

  Tangy Kapiti blue cheese and creamy goodness meet balsamic caramelized onions for a flavor fiesta!

  NZ$15.20

• Nutella

  Fix and fogg hazelnut spread, sliced banana and freeze-dried blueberries a Betsy Bagel.

  NZ$15.70

• CC

  Organic Zany Zeus cream cheese slathered on a Betsy bagel.

  NZ$13.00

• Pesto

  Creamy cream cheese topped with vibrant pesto on a Betsy bagel.

  NZ$15.70

• Vege Breakfast Bagel

  Pesto, aioli, avocado, baby spinach and a fried egg in a delicious Betsy bagel

  NZ$17.50

• PBJ

  Creamy Fix and Fogg peanut butter paired with sweet jam on a fresh Betsy bagel.

  NZ$13.00

• Breakfast Bagel

  Crispy bacon, Fried egg, finished with Betsy's own tomato relish and aioli

  NZ$17.50

• Avo & Miso

  White Miso paste blended with creamy smashed Avocado. Gluten-free option available.

  NZ$16.50

Cold Drinks

• Karma Drinks

  Your choice of flavour.

  NZ$7.00

• Aroha Juice

  Your choice of flavour.

  NZ$7.00

• 6 Barrel Soda Fizzy

  Your choice of flavour.

  NZ$7.00

Coffee

• Mocha 8 Oz

  Medium

  NZ$6.60

• Iced Maple Cold Brew

  NZ$7.70

• Latte 12 Oz

  Large

  NZ$7.00

• Kids Hot Chocolate

  NZ$5.00

• Americano

  NZ$5.00

• Long Black

  NZ$4.50

• Cappuccino 12 Oz

  Large

  NZ$7.00

• Large Mocha

  NZ$7.00

• Fluffy

  NZ$3.00

• Hot Chocolate 8 Oz

  Medium

  NZ$6.60

• Flat White 8 Oz

  Medium

  NZ$6.70

• Flat White 12 Oz

  Large

  NZ$7.50

• Iced Latte

  Espresso coffee served over ice

  NZ$7.00

• Cappuccino 6 Oz

  Small

  NZ$6.50

• Latte 8 Oz

  Medium

  NZ$6.70

• Large Hot Chocolate

  NZ$7.50

• Flat White 6 Oz

  Small

  NZ$6.50

• Cappuccino 8 Oz

  Medium

  NZ$6.70

Slices & Treats

• Cake Slice

  A slice of Betsy’s in house cake. Flavours change regularly. Check our instagram page for the latest delight.

  NZ$8.50

• Peanut Raw Slice

  Vegan, gluten free.

  NZ$6.50

• Gluten Free Doughnuts

  We make our doughnuts in store, so know exactly what goes into them. Now we offer gluten free doughnuts! Celiac's rejoice knowing we use a individual fryer to fry these beauties so they remain gluten free.

  NZ$7.50

• Donuts

  Freshly made donuts, flavours change regularly

  NZ$7.50

• Raspberry Raw Slice

  Vegan, gluten free.

  NZ$6.50

• Caramel Slice

  Gluten free.

  NZ$6.80

• Brownie

  Gluten free Rich chocolate brownie

  NZ$6.80

• Cinnamon Brioche

  Our famous in house brioche , with buttery cinnamon sugar inside

  NZ$7.50

• Banana Loaf

  Banana, chocolate and tahine loaf. Sooooo good toasted!

  NZ$6.80

Betsy Menu

• Crumpets

  Two crumpets topped with passion fruit curd, raspberry rose syrup, vanilla bean cream cheese and toasted almonds.

  NZ$19.00

• FRENCT TOAST

  Fluffy brioche toast topped with berry compote and a dollop of vanilla cream cheese.

  NZ$22.50

Shelly Bay Sourdough Toast

• Betsy Baked Beans

  Our in house made BBQ Baked Beans, served on Shelly Bay sourdough

  NZ$17.80

• Soup Of The Day

  Brimming with delightful, savory goodness, highlighting fresh, seasonal ingredients. Check our instagram for today's flavour

  NZ$12.75

• Salmon Hash Cakes

  Crispy Parmesan hash cakes crowned with smoked salmon, poached eggs, and a drizzle of dill hollandaise sauce. Gluten Free.

  NZ$22.80

• CILBER EGGS (TURKISH)

  Fried eggs, Garlic and cumin yoghurt, paprika and chilli, jalapeño and parsley oil.

  NZ$20.50

• Halloumi Toast

  Smashed avocado, creamy Zany Zeus halloumi, Shelly Bay sourdough, topped with Betsy Dukkah.

  NZ$20.50

• Pulled Lamb

  Slow braised lamb shoulder, finished with Betsy’s tomato ragout and served on Shelly Bay sourdough

  NZ$22.80

Smoothies

• Mango

  NZ$9.50

• Supergreen

  Spinach, ginger, cucumber, orange and mint. Dairy free. Perfect for your Immune system!!

  NZ$9.50

• Berry Banana

  NZ$9.50

Gourmet Toasted Sandwiches

• Beer-Braised Beef RuebenSandwich

  Beer-braised beef, ruby kraut, special sauce, Swiss cheese.

  NZ$15.80

• BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich

  BBQ pulled pork, gherkins, chipotle mayo, Swiss cheese.

  NZ$17.50

• Maple Bacon Sandwich

  Savory maple bacon paired with sweet caramelized onions, tangy Dijon mustard, and creamy brie.

  NZ$16.50

• Kimchi Sandwich

  Tangy Betsy Kimchi, creamy halloumi, zesty aioli, and rich Swiss cheese nestled between toasted slices of bread.

  NZ$15.80